A Lactation Consultant’s Story
Updated January 23rd 2026
Breastfeeding and sleep looked very different from my first child to my second. It was dangerous sleep circumstances with my firstborn that led me to make changes and then completely changed how my second born slept.
When my first was born, I wasn’t really prepared for how frequently he would need to eat. That he would eat on a 24 hour clock. I knew babies ate often (even though I wasn’t a Lactation Consultant then) and I knew he would eat during the night (which meant interrupted sleep) but I didn’t really know how that would feel.
It didn’t take long before I was feeling the effects of changes to my sleep patterns. I had this perfect, new little human who was entirely dependent upon me for food, warmth and safety and he was hungry whether it was daytime or night time.
He needed me.
I set up a sleep space for him in my bedroom thinking he’d sleep there, next to me but on his own because that’s what people on the internet said would happen. Needless to say, that’s not what happened (at first). I set up his sleep space in my room because The World Health Organization recommends rooming-in for the first 6 months of your baby’s life. This encourages better breastfeeding rates because you can easily and quickly respond to their early hunger cues and for me, it felt best to have him near me all the time.
Despite having a bassinet for him in my room, I found myself in many dangerous and scary unsafe sleep situations with my first born when it came to breastfeeding and sleeping.
Your baby’s body doesn’t make melatonin (a hormone secreted by the brain in darkness to signal sleep) until they are 3 months old. They rely on your milk. The oxytocin release during breastfeeding is designed to make both you and your baby sleepy. Add a lack of sleep to that and things can get pretty hairy if you’re on an unsafe sleep surface like a couch or a rocking chair.
I would often fall asleep holding my newborn. Think about falling asleep for a minute. Your body relaxes. If you’re holding a new infant on a chair or on your couch, and your arms relax, it’s unsafe. I fell asleep on the couch, in the nursing chair and in my bed. None of these were a safe sleep space despite the fact that beds can be a safe space when set up properly. But mine wasn’t, at first, so falling asleep on these spaces significantly increases the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).
The moment I realized I needed to make a plan
I remember waking one time (on my bed) to find he had slid down off my body and was wedged down by my waist, face down with a pillow next to him. I immediately grabbed him, held him up in the air and in that moment it felt like I watched his skin turn from a bluish hue at the time to pink. I will never know if it was my imagination or not but it was the scariest moment of my life. I knew something needed to change and from that moment, I practiced safe sleep with my baby as well as gradually worked on having him sleep in his bassinet and crib as he got older.

So how do you practice safe sleep?
Our western societies expectations don’t match normal infant physiology which makes becoming a new parent feel incredibly difficult at times. Sleeping through the night for example, is actually 5-6 hours (not 12) and is a developmental milestone, just like walking, it happens when baby is ready and not before.
This bugs the sleep trainors but sleep cannot be taught. If you think about it, all mammals know how to sleep. Dogs, cats, lions, giraffes – they all KNOW how to fall asleep and stay asleep. They wake up if they need something and then get right back to sleep. Same goes for you, me and our babies.
But the reality is, it’s hard to have your sleep interrupted so often. How are you supposed to feed your baby on demand and also sleep?! The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine recently released new evidence-based protocols around breastfeeding and infant sleep and sleeping within arms reach to your baby is best for you both (linked below).
It allows you both to return to sleep sooner and actually get more sleep overall. Arms reach could mean a bassinet in your room, a sidecar crib or safe sleep in your bed. The research shows that breastfeeding infants sleeping next to their mothers (in a side lying position in the absence of risk factors) ‘may be the safest strategy for maternal and infant wellbeing‘.
How do you set up for safe bed sharing?
Safe bedsharing literally means you’re sleeping on the same surface as your baby, usually your bed. There are many cultures throughout the world where this is the norm and for some families, it’s the only option because they don’t have multiple empty bedrooms in their home.
In order for your bed to be a safe space for your baby, you need to make a few changes including:
- Having a firm mattress (your pillow top has to go) that doesn’t have any gaps around it (e.g. the gap between a bed and night table)
- Removing pillows and extra blankets. The comforter should only cover you up to your waist so wear something up top that will keep you warm
- Your baby needs to be exclusively breastfeed if you’re going to sleep together and they should be lying on their back if they are not nursing
- You cannot be a smoker or consuming large amounts of alcohol or taking medications that will make you drowsy
- Your baby should be lightly dressed to prevent overheating (a risk factors for SIDS)
La Leche League calls these the Safe Sleep 7
Nursing to sleep can be a superpower – don’t let anyone tell you it’s a bad habit
Nursing my first to sleep was my superpower. 99% of the time, I could nurse him before a nap or bedtime (or in the middle of the night) and he’d go to sleep. It made things easier
My second – not always. Sometimes I nurse him thinking “ok, great this is it. He’ll fall asleep now” only to have him stop and look at me and smile – and stay awake
But with my first, I used my superpower every chance I got, even when he was a toddler. Even when society told me not to. Even when some IG accounts told me otherwise. Even when I didn’t know anyone else nursing a baby. Even when I felt alone at the 3:30am feeding
I continued to use my superpower to nurse my baby to sleep because lactation is made to work this way
If nursing to sleep was a bad habit, your body wouldn’t adjust the hormones in your milk come night time.
The release of oxytocin wouldn’t make you both sleepy.
Prolactin levels wouldn’t increase at night to increase your production.
Your baby wouldn’t need to be 3 months before they were able to make melatonin and a circadian rhythm developed.
Human lactation would look very different if we weren’t meant to feed our babies to sleep and at night.
Don’t let anyone tell you nursing your baby to sleep is a bad habit (or a negative sleep association or a sleep prop or sleep crutch). If it’s working for YOU and YOU like it that way, then keep doing what’s working
ALL babies and toddlers stop breastfeeding to sleep at some point. I know it’s cliche for me to say but it’s factually true. For my oldest, he was 11 months. I would nurse him before nap and most often, he would still be awake. I weaned him completely around 17 months and it’s not a surprise that he was still able to fall asleep. We showed him love and connection in other ways.
My youngest at the time I’m writing this is 18 months and he nurses to sleep for his nap and bedtime. He’s able to fall asleep without nursing however and does so when he’s home with my husband and I’m not there. Supporting our children to sleep has always been important to us.

But what if it’s not working?
What if you feel like something is wrong or you’re having a really hard time trying to help your baby fall asleep all the time. What if they’re waking so often it’s making you feel like there are no other options?
There are people out there who want you to believe that leaving your baby to cry it out is the best way to support them. That somehow removing support is supporting. It doesn’t make any sense to me and we have research that tells us otherwise.
Our babies need to borrow our nervous systems to help themselves regulate. They co-regulate with us.
Our babies need to borrow our nervous systems to help themselves regulate. They co-regulate with us. So if you’re feeling like there could be some changes or improvements to your little one’s sleep and you’re not a fan of just leaving them to cry, I’d like to introduce you to Isla-Grace.
Sleep Without Sleep Training from Isla-Grace was created to help you navigate the challenges and frustrations around baby sleep in the first 18 months.
“There is so much information out there on parenting and sleep and it can be overwhelming. It can be hard to filter out all of the “should’s” and really follow your heart…we will walk you through 44 modules that cover everything you need to know about NORMAL INFANT sleep, common sleep challenges and how to navigate these, as well as making changes to the parts of your nighttime parenting routine that are no longer working. We will give you SCIENCE and FACT-BASED information to help you make your own decisions about what works best for your UNIQUE family.”
ISLA GRACE SLEEP
I support the approach that Isla-Grace has because it is evidenced based and designed to help you find the confidence that you need to follow your instincts and your heart to navigate your baby’s sleep, all without sleep training meaning you’re not ever leaving your baby to cry or taking away any connection, comfort or support from them.


References:
ABM Clinical Protocol #37: Physiological Infant Care—Managing Nighttime
Breastfeeding in Young Infants: https://abm.memberclicks.net/assets/DOCUMENTS/PROTOCOLS/Physiologic%20Infant%20Care%20Protocol%2037.pdf
Disclosure: The program link above is NOT an affiliate link. If you resonate with Isla-Grace and their approach to infant sleep and make the decision to invest in a course, I do NOT earn any money. I am sharing a resource I believe in from a holistic approach to postpartum, breastfeeding and motherhood.


















